My local shop recommended this tip and after 3 weeks I think it is great. I have the super soft, which on soft hits gives great action to the cue ball, and on medium to hard hits does not feel soft or squishy at all.
It has improved my draw shots significantly as lots of draw using a soft to medium hit is possible. There is no mushrooming so far, and the solid black color looks great. I was using standard quality , name brand medium tips and this tip is a big improvement for subtle cue ball control. Considering a tip lasts a couple of years or so, the cost is not a major factor. I am a grade B player who shoots in a very competitive league and have been shooting for many years. So far this tip is 5 stars for sure. Willyboy